Lots of new things on the horizon for years to come, as we seem to be close to the amended health reform bill which is getting ready for an Obama signature.
The public option is dead, but it sounds like insurance carriers will not be able to medically underwrite sick folks, or imposed pre-existing condition language. The fear is how we pay for this? We need to have both healthy low utilizers in the new system along with the 5-8% of the population which drives 95% of the high claims. Without healthy offsetting sick, not sure that premiums will not radically rise.
We also need ala carte care, for example, if we have already had our children, why should we need maternity care in our policy? Also, if I prefer pharmacy, hospital, doc visits, but not speech therapy, occupational or physical therapy and no mental health benefit, shouldn't I be able to also carve that out? These are more individual health care questions, but perhaps in a group environment we will see this choice too.
Our system is so, so broken -
Monday, December 28, 2009
Saturday, November 21, 2009
Where is Reform?
At healthinsurancegeeks.com, we spend lots of our time educating small companies about health insurance, how it works, why it is "broken" right now, and taking apart the myth that we hear on all of the news channels that follow our mislead government. Speaking from an apolitical stance, both sides have it completely wrong and are not talking about the problem. Here is the problem, we have no CONSUMERISM in healthcare. Anyone working over the last 20 years that got used to the 2, 5, 10, 15 copays will understand this.... if i have a visit that costs 20,000 or 1,000 and I pay 2, or 10 bucks for it, what do I care? If EVERYONE had a small deductible to meet before anything was reimbursed, and copayments evaporated in to thin air, and we had the choice of huge networks of physicians, but the monthly premium dropped dramatically, wouldn't that work? That is the deal from how we see it, if we went "back to the future" before copays came on to the scene, and had deductibles and coinsurance for EVERYTHING, we would fix this broken system overnight. This way, we all pay our fair share. Maximum out of pockets expenses would be capped so none of us go bankrupt, and perhaps the government could backstop some of the reinsurance for insurance companies? The problem with the politicical debate is none of them are talking about this solution, because it is so simple it will make them all look quite foolish.
They are at a stalemate, the insurance companies know this will work (that is where we the founders of healthinsurancegeeks.com started our careers, at one of the largest, fastest growing insurance companies in the world in the early 1990s) but do not want to give up their greedy profit schemes....and the politicians "probably" know this will work, but remember they are politicians not insurance experts! Lobbyists step in and now all of a sudden, they need to throw their weight. Sorry to go on a diatribe, but as an expert in this field, someone who has accessed care, and a married father of 4, I understand this as a regular American. We switched our own EPO plan to a high deductible health plan, effective January 1, 2010, as the premium absolutely sank, to 1/3 of what I was paying, we have taken on a big deductible, but get to use network doctors who via their contract with our new carrier, must accept the payments/contracted rates when we visit. That means our copays go "bye-bye" but when we take our kids to the pediatrician, rather than paying 100-125 for a sick visit, we pay 50-60 per the negotiated pricing. Not bad considering my premium sank, I am able to open an HSA if I so choose, and my doctor visits are really only going up from 30-60 per say, as our old plan had a $30 copay.
This is not magic, it is just plain old consumerism at it's best.
They are at a stalemate, the insurance companies know this will work (that is where we the founders of healthinsurancegeeks.com started our careers, at one of the largest, fastest growing insurance companies in the world in the early 1990s) but do not want to give up their greedy profit schemes....and the politicians "probably" know this will work, but remember they are politicians not insurance experts! Lobbyists step in and now all of a sudden, they need to throw their weight. Sorry to go on a diatribe, but as an expert in this field, someone who has accessed care, and a married father of 4, I understand this as a regular American. We switched our own EPO plan to a high deductible health plan, effective January 1, 2010, as the premium absolutely sank, to 1/3 of what I was paying, we have taken on a big deductible, but get to use network doctors who via their contract with our new carrier, must accept the payments/contracted rates when we visit. That means our copays go "bye-bye" but when we take our kids to the pediatrician, rather than paying 100-125 for a sick visit, we pay 50-60 per the negotiated pricing. Not bad considering my premium sank, I am able to open an HSA if I so choose, and my doctor visits are really only going up from 30-60 per say, as our old plan had a $30 copay.
This is not magic, it is just plain old consumerism at it's best.
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Bill Clinton on CNBC
Whether conservative, liberal, super left or super right, it was interesting to watch former President Bill Clinton this morning on CNBC. He articulated perfectly what is wrong with the healthcare system in the U.S. and it has NOTHING to do with not having a public option, or whether we pay17% or more of our GDP on healthcare spending....it is all about outcomes. He referenced Columbia where they spend 6% of GDP on healthcare and have a much higher outcomes rating than the U.S. The problem is on governance of the healthcare process, especially on physicians and hospitals, which can happen between government, insurance carriers and providers. A public plan is such a radical (far left) change to the current system, that most agree we do not need to be so radical, though we do need a big change. This can be done pushing providers, and insurance carriers, to be regulated and incented based on outcomes. The better a patient gets, and more efficiently, means better compensation to the provider and institution (read up on the Cleveland Clinic, and Mayo Clinic). Providers and institutions that do not have good outcomes, will go out of business - just like in the REAL world....poor business models fail and go bankrupt. Same should be true for healthcare.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Obamacare
Is Obamacare officially dead? As an internet insurance entrepreneur, I have mutliple news channels on all day every day, and they all say the same thing - what about Medical Malpractice tort and the costs of defensive medicine and unnecessary testing...these numbers are not small, they are as high as 30% of the healthcare spend! I will say one thing whether I support one side of the isle or the other "politically" I do not want uneducated (on healthcare anyway) politicians driving our healthcare system in an unhealthy direction in order to win their seats the next go-around, or to get happy lobbying/self-interest support. It is very scary to think one of my 4 kids could be denied care, as the Obamacare and House-supported model right now, does not focus on the core problem - our system does not have consumerism now...if I pay a 25$ copay for a service that is $400, or $400,000, what do I care as a consumer? Believe me, my employer cares. If I have a sick child or loved one, I do not want the government looking at statistics telling me what we can and cannot do. I am also fine with paying my fair share as we all should be in the U.S. Why does everyone come to these terrific institutions we have in the U.S. for their healthcare? Because it is the best.....we all do need to pay our fair share though, that is another problem...the healthly are not offsetting all of the sick in todays' system.
Why doesn't the government just backstop large claims and the chronically ill folks in the nation (5% of the population drives 49% of the spending) for the private insurance industry, and as a take back enforce stronger regulation, and profit restrictions? All medical records being electronic like the Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinics do respectively (arguably 2 of the best institutions in the world!)?
We need to get politicians out of the debate and start fixing the real problem here....let's have bipartisan, outside entities with expertise in this area assist reform, instead of politicians elbowing for votes please!
Why doesn't the government just backstop large claims and the chronically ill folks in the nation (5% of the population drives 49% of the spending) for the private insurance industry, and as a take back enforce stronger regulation, and profit restrictions? All medical records being electronic like the Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinics do respectively (arguably 2 of the best institutions in the world!)?
We need to get politicians out of the debate and start fixing the real problem here....let's have bipartisan, outside entities with expertise in this area assist reform, instead of politicians elbowing for votes please!
Friday, August 28, 2009
Healthcare Reform and some valid Statistics
Medicare passed in 1966, and at that point in time the private sector (the insurance we as Americas have state in 2009 that we like over 85% of the time - employer-sponsored or buy it ourselves, or if we own small businesses etc...) funded over 75% of total healthcare expenditures. Following that percentage began to pull back and fell to 63% by 1967. Since that time the private sector has continued to fund less of the national health expenditures.
As of 2007 that number was down to 53%. Why? Again, we reference the "health care wedge" which is the separation of the consumer and provider as there began to be more and more government intervention through this time period. What is amazing, if we compare this phenomenon to auto insurance, or other types of insurance (life etc..) which by definition is a tool to manage risk, and in exchange for premium payments, provides protection against large but uncertain risks. We have completely flopsided the way health care is purchased, and for what services. There is a great article now by Laffer & Moore that I am referencing (The Prognosis for National Health Insurance) and in it they compare auto insurance paying for oil changes, brakes, you name it. Even a layman can quickly state "wow, wouldn't that cost way more?" Answer is simple and yes.
As the government has already intervened, driven this wedge up, and taken control of the payment and funding methodology almost half of the time as of 2007, the spike in health care spending is actually more because of the existing system that has pulled away from the private sector funding versus the government. As an expert in this field, I quickly jump to, "well, go back to the 60's before the government destroyed the system with it's now bankrupt Medicare program, and completely reformed by whom and how Medicare is run and funded. Government already seems to be the obvious problem here."
Back to my example above, again referencing Laffer & Moore, now the private sector funds just above 50% of health care expenditures, with only slighltly more than $1 out of ever $10 coming out of the consumer's pocket (no consumerism here either). Where was that number in 1960? It was about 47%, or $4.70 out of every $10. So today, and back to the automotive example, if we overlayed (apply?) this to the auto industry, pricing would be fixed whether you crash all the time or not, or whether you are 21 years of age or 50, and the "reckless" would be funding the "safe."
This does not appear to be a fair system, and does not promote any type of "thinking" before we research or spend. If I can go to a $400 dollar a visit cardiologist 5 times a month just to check in, and it does not cost me very much (but is killing the overall system), why wouldn't I?
I can go on and on, but my point is straight-forward and simple. The private industry NEEDS to control more of health care funding and expenditures, and we as Americans also need good tools to use to research, examine, and compare doctor's and hospitals to see their outcomes, infection rates, readmission rates, etc. If I choose a doctor that my mother says is incredible - "we all go to her" - but that doctor readmits patients to the hospital for the same services over and over because their health immediately deteriorates after they are released, does it seem like a problem? Yes, maybe I would like more information on this physician and her practice patterns? It is a proven fact that most American's spend more time researching the purchase of their new SUV than they do gathering information before having a hip replacement. Amazing isn't it? We need more of this valuable information to help American's see that what most politicians say on TV is self-motivated by lobbying interests and perhaps not always with an eye on the common good of us as tax-payers. I can beat up on both Republicans and Democrats on this very point, for they are the government. Private insurers, if regulated differently, and if their cost structures change to bring down the enormous profits they make at the expense of consumers in this country solves two problems. First, it would make affordability radically increase and coverage availability soar. Second, it would place the profit mechanism for businesses that want to sell health insurance under much greater scrutiny and management.
Enough for now...please provide comments.
As of 2007 that number was down to 53%. Why? Again, we reference the "health care wedge" which is the separation of the consumer and provider as there began to be more and more government intervention through this time period. What is amazing, if we compare this phenomenon to auto insurance, or other types of insurance (life etc..) which by definition is a tool to manage risk, and in exchange for premium payments, provides protection against large but uncertain risks. We have completely flopsided the way health care is purchased, and for what services. There is a great article now by Laffer & Moore that I am referencing (The Prognosis for National Health Insurance) and in it they compare auto insurance paying for oil changes, brakes, you name it. Even a layman can quickly state "wow, wouldn't that cost way more?" Answer is simple and yes.
As the government has already intervened, driven this wedge up, and taken control of the payment and funding methodology almost half of the time as of 2007, the spike in health care spending is actually more because of the existing system that has pulled away from the private sector funding versus the government. As an expert in this field, I quickly jump to, "well, go back to the 60's before the government destroyed the system with it's now bankrupt Medicare program, and completely reformed by whom and how Medicare is run and funded. Government already seems to be the obvious problem here."
Back to my example above, again referencing Laffer & Moore, now the private sector funds just above 50% of health care expenditures, with only slighltly more than $1 out of ever $10 coming out of the consumer's pocket (no consumerism here either). Where was that number in 1960? It was about 47%, or $4.70 out of every $10. So today, and back to the automotive example, if we overlayed (apply?) this to the auto industry, pricing would be fixed whether you crash all the time or not, or whether you are 21 years of age or 50, and the "reckless" would be funding the "safe."
This does not appear to be a fair system, and does not promote any type of "thinking" before we research or spend. If I can go to a $400 dollar a visit cardiologist 5 times a month just to check in, and it does not cost me very much (but is killing the overall system), why wouldn't I?
I can go on and on, but my point is straight-forward and simple. The private industry NEEDS to control more of health care funding and expenditures, and we as Americans also need good tools to use to research, examine, and compare doctor's and hospitals to see their outcomes, infection rates, readmission rates, etc. If I choose a doctor that my mother says is incredible - "we all go to her" - but that doctor readmits patients to the hospital for the same services over and over because their health immediately deteriorates after they are released, does it seem like a problem? Yes, maybe I would like more information on this physician and her practice patterns? It is a proven fact that most American's spend more time researching the purchase of their new SUV than they do gathering information before having a hip replacement. Amazing isn't it? We need more of this valuable information to help American's see that what most politicians say on TV is self-motivated by lobbying interests and perhaps not always with an eye on the common good of us as tax-payers. I can beat up on both Republicans and Democrats on this very point, for they are the government. Private insurers, if regulated differently, and if their cost structures change to bring down the enormous profits they make at the expense of consumers in this country solves two problems. First, it would make affordability radically increase and coverage availability soar. Second, it would place the profit mechanism for businesses that want to sell health insurance under much greater scrutiny and management.
Enough for now...please provide comments.
Thursday, August 27, 2009
Obamacare?
It was been a while since I blogged on this subject, but the Obama plan seems to have lost most of it's muster and it's steam. Most economists, and folks from both sides of the isle seems to think we will see insurance reform, but perhaps this turns more in to insurance carriers being reformed in the private market. Seems to us that if pre-existing condition exclusions are removed, and guaranteed issue coverage takes a national state (like they have in NY, NJ, CT, MD for example) that would certainly be a piece of the pie. But there will invariably need to be business tax credits for folks that offer group coverage to their employees, and tax penalties if folks do not, which would in turn offset the internal cost structure to insurance carriers in order to be able to have bigger pools of people (both healthy and sick) to bring down premiums. What seems to have sunk the Obama plan is the fact that an already bankrupt Medicare and Medicaid government run program, if given the opportunity to bring in a government plan for all (the Public Option) would then force hospitals and private physicians to take drastically lower reimbursements, hence forcing them to drive up their charges to the privately-insured - this in turn would radically push private insurance higher, and also force providers to increase the already staggering 29% of Medicare covered senior (and then now also non-seniors with a public option) to run in to access issues - this 29% has been referenced many times in all forms of media, as the percentage of people covered under Medicare that can't get treatment because physicians prefer to not treat for such low reimbursements when they can see privately-covered patients and more reasonable reimbursements.... I have not even starting talking about Medical Malpractice tort etc...another huge piece of the pie.
That brings us to the place we are today, we need everyone in a room together, insurance companies, doctors, hospitals, and legislators, working out a better private system to continue to give Americans access to the best healthcare in the world. We have lots of work to do -
That brings us to the place we are today, we need everyone in a room together, insurance companies, doctors, hospitals, and legislators, working out a better private system to continue to give Americans access to the best healthcare in the world. We have lots of work to do -
Monday, July 13, 2009
Best priced NYC area health plans 2009
It almost seems an oxymoron to say "best priced" with where premiums for health insurance plans have risen in the last 5 years. Having said that, if small businesses are looking for the lowest premium on the market, Health Net and Emblem Health have the best community rated products right now. Empire BCBS has introduced some new EPO plans as well that are also quite competitive. If employers are looking for high-deductible health plans to couple with HSA or HRAs, Emblem Health has plans are that below 200/person.
Oxford Health Plans and Aetna are priced similarly to each other, as such, their products and prices are the next tier up. Cigna now has also introduced an EPO plan that is also quite competitive.
For folks over the river in to New Jersey, Horizon BCBS has the best price/product mix right now, followed by Health Net and others including Oxford and Aetna as well.
For free quotes, visit www.healthinsurancegeeks.com, for New York companies there is a real time quote engine, for NJ, folks must submit a census document to get a quote right back as the carriers rate based on census.
Oxford Health Plans and Aetna are priced similarly to each other, as such, their products and prices are the next tier up. Cigna now has also introduced an EPO plan that is also quite competitive.
For folks over the river in to New Jersey, Horizon BCBS has the best price/product mix right now, followed by Health Net and others including Oxford and Aetna as well.
For free quotes, visit www.healthinsurancegeeks.com, for New York companies there is a real time quote engine, for NJ, folks must submit a census document to get a quote right back as the carriers rate based on census.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)